Retired Andorra Doctor on Trial for Negligent Care Causing Elderly Woman's Rib Fractures
An 81-year-old patient endured repeated falls at Salita care home in Escaldes-Engordany under a retired doctor's oversight, resulting in severe rib injuries from negligence. Trial reveals staffing shortages and protocol failures eight years later.
Key Points
- 68-year-old retired doctor failed to diagnose 82-year-old woman's six rib fractures after three falls during 15-day Respir programme stay in 2018.
- Prosecutors seek 4 months conditional arrest, 20 months disqualification for skipping X-ray despite pain indicators.
- Family claims neglect, overmedication; defence blames protocol, family decisions on monitoring.
- Civil claims total €112,490; case awaits verdict after three-day trial.
A retired doctor from Salita care home in Escaldes-Engordany has completed trial at Andorra's Tribunal de Corts for minor bodily harm through serious professional negligence, with the case now awaiting a verdict after closing arguments on its third and final day.
Prosecutors and the private accusation maintained their demands, arguing the 68-year-old physician—retired for three years—failed to diagnose rib fractures in an 82-year-old woman during her 15-day stay under the government’s Respir programme starting 2 May 2018. The patient experienced three falls, leading to six fractured ribs, a pleural effusion and respiratory infection identified post-discharge. Her children described her as drowsy, disoriented and in pain, attributing issues to neglect and deviations from prescribed medication despite providing drugs, documentation and bed rails on admission. The family had no record of prior home falls and denied blocking a hospital transfer.
The doctor first examined her on 10 May, eight days after admission and following her initial bed fall. He recorded right-side pain near the shoulder blade, diagnosed a possible contusion or strain, and prescribed rest and painkillers without imaging or referral. After further falls, he discussed transfer with a daughter, claiming she opted to wait as pain appeared managed. He maintained that nursing and physiotherapy handled incidents first, with only complex cases escalating to him, and rejected overmedication claims.
Former director Ernest Sáiz noted Respir admissions skipped standard protocols but required a doctor’s review within about 24 hours, though timings differed. A falls log existed; family complaints triggered a Health Ministry inspection, prompting organizational changes including a nursing coordinator’s dismissal. Nurses described night shifts with one nurse and an aide overseeing roughly 80 residents across floors, hindering checks. Protocols later strengthened post-inspection. The doctor called the family “difficult,” a characterization disputed by Sáiz and staff.
Prosecutors requested four months’ conditional nighttime arrest, 20 months’ professional disqualification and court costs, citing breaches of medical norms by skipping an X-ray despite falls and pain indicators. The fiscal emphasized imaging was essential, as five experts confirmed, with responsibility lying solely with the doctor—not the family—and a clear causal link to her decline. The patient’s cognitive vulnerability aggravated the matter. The private prosecution echoed these points, highlighting her senile dementia, the delayed eighth-day visit after her third fall, ignored family prevention requests and emotional impact on relatives.
Civil claims totaled around €112,490: €107,000 from the family—including €25,000 for the victim (now nearing 90), €20,000 each for three children, €22,000 for the late husband, €1,971 for incapacitation proceedings and other costs—plus CASS’s €3,519.26 for pre-hospital expenses against the insurer and centre.
The defence sought acquittal, arguing the centre’s protocol routed initial assessments to nursing and physiotherapy, with the doctor intervening as needed. Clinical notes showed no early red flags; upon examination, he considered a fracture, discussed imaging with family—who jointly decided to monitor evolution—and noted pain improvement days 11-16, justifying conservative treatment with rest and analgesics. The lawyer invoked the “hindsight bull” theory, warning against judging actions by later outcomes or “criminalizing medicine,” which could spur unnecessary tests for self-protection. As fallback, they proposed no more than one month’s arrest and four months’ disqualification, plus modest indemnities: up to €4,000 per family member and €3,500 for the victim.
In final remarks, the doctor cited his 35-year career without prior malpractice claims but admitted not documenting the alleged family conversation on delaying urgent care. Pain remission reinforced his strain diagnosis over fracture. “My actions were correct,” he told the court.
The patient, now severely cognitively impaired and unable to testify, later received incapacity status as her condition worsened irreversibly post-falls. Salita has seen subsequent complaints, including four under Social Affairs review in March 2023 and one police-reported restraint fall. A conviction would engage Salita’s liability, potentially exceeding prior €30,000 estimates.
Related Articles
Other articles from Catalan-language sources about the same story:
- Diari d'Andorra•
‘Cas Salita’: l’acusació vol 112.000 euros
- Diari d'Andorra•
L’acusació demana de 107.000 euros de responsabilitat civil al metge de Salita per mala praxi
- Diari d'Andorra•
Protocols sanitaris, a judici
- Altaveu•
El primer cas de sobremedicació fa evident les deficiències a Salita: "Una desorganització terrible"
- Altaveu•
Salita reconeix dues multes de Salut i una remodelació d'infermeria arran del cas de sobre medicació
- Altaveu•
El Tribunal de Corts jutja el primer cas de suposada sobre medicació denunciat a Salita