Andorra Bans iPads in Primary Schools Over Security Gaps After Kids Access Adult Content
Andorra's Education Department has permanently ruled out iPads in primary schools due to unfixable security flaws exposed by a recent audit and a student incident involving adult content.
Key Points
- Audit of 97 iPads found 20 fully failed security tests after pupils accessed sexual content.
- Apple's School Manager unavailable in Andorra, allowing app reinstalls and hotspots to bypass filters.
- 380 aging iPads to be repurposed; primaries switch to desktops, laptops, and Chromebooks.
- Parents' association praises ban, urges home monitoring and balanced digital education.
Andorra's Education Department has permanently banned iPads from primary school classrooms after an audit revealed unresolvable security vulnerabilities, including the lack of Apple's School Manager tool in the country.
State Secretary for Education and Universities Josep Anton Bardina and Director of Professional Training, Adult Education, and Educational Resources Xavier Campuzano announced the policy during a briefing on the revised school technology strategy. The decision stemmed from a June 19 incident in which pupils accessed inappropriate sexual content on the devices, prompting their immediate withdrawal from primary classes and an external review with Andorra Telecom.
The audit examined 97 iPads via roughly 90,000 tests: 68 met full security standards, nine achieved partial compliance, and 20 failed completely. Andorra's XENA education network successfully filters non-educational material on Windows computers and Chromebooks in secondary schools, but iPads proved susceptible to workarounds like switching from XENA Wi-Fi to mobile hotspots or app updates that sidestepped restrictions.
Campuzano noted that School Manager, essential for complete device management, remains unavailable despite prolonged talks with Apple. "With the tools at our disposal, we cannot prevent certain apps from being reinstalled," he stated, citing Andorra's limited bargaining power.
Some 380 iPads, most over five years old, face repurposing rather than replacement. About 60 will move to lifelong learning centers, while primary schools will use desktops, laptop carts, and modified lesson plans. Secure Chromebooks and Windows devices could shift to primary use.
The restriction covers only primary education, with officials clarifying that iPads and Chromebooks have no intrinsic flaws—only that iPads cannot match local oversight levels.
Mireia Muñoz, manager of the Andorran School Parents' Association (AMPAEA), praised the move as "the right decision" given unresolved safety issues. She stressed shared responsibility in digital education, urging families to monitor device and social media use at home. "What concerns me now is how we act at home, because in the end the ministry makes decisions, but children have lives beyond school," Muñoz said. "We are the main ones responsible for young people's use of the digital environment, especially at home."
Muñoz rejected any shift away from digital learning overall, insisting pupils must build competencies for a tech-driven future. She called for debate on optimal introduction timing—perhaps second or third primary cycles—and integration, such as limited use in math alongside group work and hands-on activities. AMPAEA expressed trust in the ministry's swift audit response and seeks secure alternatives plus collaboration among officials, teachers, and parents.
Related Articles
Other articles from Catalan-language sources about the same story:
- El Periòdic•
La retirada definitiva dels iPads, una oportunitat per replantejar quan i com entra la tecnologia als centres escolars
- El Periòdic•
La retirada definitiva dels iPads, una oportunitat per replantejar quan i com entra la tecnologia a les aules
- Diari d'Andorra•
Un “no” rotund als iPads
- El Periòdic•
Tecnologia sí, però amb garanties des del primer dia
- Altaveu•
Les famílies avalen la retirada dels iPads i defensen educar en l'ús de la tecnologia
- Altaveu•
Educació desterra els iPads de les aules en considerar que no són prou segurs
- El Periòdic•
Els riscos de seguretat detectats en els iPads deixen els dispositius fora de les aules escolars de primera ensenyança
- Diari d'Andorra•
Els iPads no tornaran a les aules de primera ensenyança de l’Escola Andorrana
- Bon Dia•
El iPad no tornaran a l'escola
- Altaveu•
Els iPads no tornaran a les escoles de primària