Back to home
Politics·

Andorra Court Orders Government to Pay Parishes €6,492 in 2017 Tax Dispute

Andorra's Superior Court of Justice has mandated a €6,492 payment to the seven parishes over a long-standing fiscal transfer dispute rooted in 1993 law interpretations. Parish officials are evaluating a potential appeal.

Key Points

  • Superior Court upholds government's tax transfer method based on actual collections, not billings.
  • Orders €6,492 payment for minor discrepancy in 2017 transfers from 2016 revenues.
  • Dispute stems from 1993 law interpretations; parishes eye Constitutional Court appeal.
  • Government welcomes ruling as validation of cash-based system amid decade-long conflict.

Andorra's Superior Court of Justice has ordered the government to pay the seven parishes €6,492 over a dispute concerning 2017 fiscal transfers, a ruling that upholds the administration's calculation approach while parishes consider a Constitutional Court appeal.

The decision largely backs the government's method, based on actual tax collections rather than billed amounts, and follows nearly a decade of contention. It identifies only a minor €6,492 difference between the €62,149,486.55 transferred and the correct €62,155,978 figure—at 18% of €345,310,989.30 in relevant 2016 revenues, excluding property transfer and vehicle taxes assigned directly to parishes.

The conflict traces to interpretations of the 1993 Qualified Law on Transfers to Parishes, which grants parishes 18% of tax revenues "assessed, settled, and accountably allocated to the General Administration Budget, effectively realised in the previous year." Parishes sought regularisation of €7,573,772.65—or €1,081,408.45 alternatively—based on 2016 billings. The government rejected the claim in September 2021, confirmed the denial in January 2022, and prevailed at the Batllia court this April. The Superior Court affirmed that position, adjusting solely for late-payment overlaps.

Parish leaders plan to review the judgment with legal advisors before deciding on a Constitutional challenge, their last ordinary recourse. Ordino's senior consul, Maria del Mar Coma, stated that no choice has been made: "Neither ruled out nor decided—we must assess what to do next." She described such an appeal as "difficult," given setbacks over the years. Ordino's Jordi Alcobé expressed frustration but limited options to proceed.

Government spokesperson Minister Guillem Casal hailed the outcome as validation of the cash-based system. "We are very pleased. The government was very clear with the parishes at the time that the calculation based on settled amounts was fair, and the ruling confirms it," he said following the Council of Ministers meeting, calling the compensation "risible" with negligible fiscal effect.

Casal defended the prior role of Presidency Minister Conxita Marsol, then Andorra la Vella's senior consul and a key advocate alongside Escaldes-Engordany's Rosa Gili. "Nothing has been held against her. She defended Andorra la Vella's interests, just as others who have moved from parishes to government have done," he said. The issue arose amid 2016 revenue reforms under then-head of government Toni Martí.

Share the article via